Government agencies have spent years adopting agile delivery, human-centered design, and product thinking. So why do teams still struggle to make government services work better?
Too often, the problem isn't the approach. It's how agencies make decisions and manage their work.
At the Digital Service Coalition's Great Digital Debate, Fearless' Luqman Green joined Delaware CTO Greg Godbout, Virginia Director of Operations Christina Schildroth, and Erica Evans of the U.S. Digital Service to make the case that digital services is more relevant than ever. Human-centered design, iterative delivery, and multidisciplinary teams remain essential to improving government services, even as technology and delivery models evolve.
The principles still work. It's time to address what's getting in their way.
Digital services teams can't change government on their own
Digital services teams can change how they build technology, but they don't necessarily have the authority to change how an agency operates. And that's where even the best approaches run into trouble.
Approvals can make it hard to try new ideas. Requirements may be locked in before teams have a chance to respond to user feedback. And contracts may measure hours worked rather than whether services improve.
Even when leaders overcome these barriers, progress doesn't always last. Organizations can adopt better ways of working under one leader, then return to old habits when that person leaves.
If improvements depend on one individual, they haven't become part of how the organization operates.
Better services require looking beyond individual systems
Consider someone applying for Medicaid or SNAP.
They may need to navigate multiple websites, programs, and departments because that's how government has divided responsibility.
Each agency might be fulfilling its responsibilities. But who's accountable for whether someone successfully completes the application?
Improving individual systems won't fix a fragmented experience if the processes behind them remain disconnected. Digital services needs to address more than technology, including how agencies work together to deliver a service.
New Jersey took this approach with Business.NJ.gov, bringing experts from five state agencies together to support business owners through a single live chat. Instead of figuring out which agency to contact, business owners can get help in one place. Fearless worked with the state to make that coordination possible.
Three questions to ask if you want digital services improvements to last
Before investing in another system or launching a new initiative, look at one service your agency already delivers. These three questions can help identify what's preventing it from working better.
1. Who owns the service from beginning to end?
People don't experience government services one department at a time, but that's often how agencies manage them.
Follow the process from the public's perspective. Where do people get stuck? Which departments are involved? And who has the authority to fix problems that cross those boundaries?
When IT manages the system, a program office handles eligibility, and another team provides support, someone still needs to be accountable for whether people can complete the process.
2. Can teams act on what they learn?
User research and testing only matter if teams can use what they discover.
Think about the last time your team identified a problem. Could they make a change, or did existing requirements, contracts, or approval processes stand in the way?
Identify one recurring obstacle and determine what it would take to remove it. The goal isn't less accountability. It's giving teams the flexibility to improve services while maintaining appropriate oversight.
3. Will improvements survive a leadership change?
A successful project doesn't necessarily mean an agency has changed how it operates.
If a leader who champions digital services leaves, will teams continue conducting user research, measuring outcomes, and improving services based on what they learn?
Making those practices part of everyday operations, with clear responsibilities and decision-making authority, helps ensure progress continues even as leaders and contractors change.
Making digital services work for the long term
Government agencies need contracts that allow teams to respond to what they learn, leaders who can resolve problems across departments, and ways to measure whether services are actually improving. Digital services companies have a responsibility to support those changes, not simply deliver technology within existing constraints.
That's the work ahead for our industry. We don't need to replace the principles behind digital services. We need to make sure government can actually use them.
The real test is whether people can get the services they need, and whether government can keep improving that experience.
